"I have a simple message: The Federal government should do the right first things, first. Change should begin with those who promised Change!"
As if the current unclear economic
policy context was not disconcerting enough, the sudden emergence of a raging
debate on the sale of public assets has escalated one’s fears that easier
things seem to appear more attractive to the government. Yet, in public policy,
it is wise to be wary of the easiest options.
As a pro
market economy advocate, I inherently support any programme of government that
will help roll back the public sector from the economy because economic
evidence shows this to be almost always correct. However, lacking the sound
economic management and policy context as yet, I am presently opposed to what
sounds like a proposal for “distress option” sale of public stakes, especially
in NNPC and NLNG. But the government can proceed urgently through the Bureau of
Public Enterprises (BPE) to sell off those cesspools of corruption in our
petroleum sector otherwise known as refineries. Their sale would in fact amount
to fiscal savings beyond the proceeds and should therefore be supported by all.
I am
opposed to the sale of any productive assets like the NLNG because there seems
to be no clear economic vision and rigorous analytics to serve as the anchor
for such a major policy thrust. We need well deliberated policies from our
government including the plans for revitalization of the programme of
privatization being run by BPE to properly situate public debate of economic
structural change agenda. After all, even in our country, there is now proof
that the economy can relatively respond to deliberate, well thought and
rigorous analysis of context and sound policy options in resolving growth and
development problems.
The
evidence that backs this is that it was a modest range of such sound economic
policies that helped deliver an average of 5-6 percent growth of our economy on
a sustained basis over a long period of nearly a decade and half. It was only
recently at the end of 2015 that growth dropped to below 3 percent.
True, the
relatively impressive economic growth rate did not resolve the major challenges
of poverty, unemployment and inequality. That 61 percent of our population is
poor, according to the Nigerian Bureau of Statistics (2011 Household Survey) is
indicative of how growth and poverty reduction can often times disconnect.
Also, according to NBS, unemployment rate stood at 10.5 percent at end of 2015
and grew to 13.3 percent by the second quarter of 2016, revealing that the
economy is severely failing to absorb new entrants into the labor market —
especially the 2-2.5 million youths that seek to do so annually.
With a
high income inequality rate of .4 Gini-coefficient instead of a score closer to
a perfect zero, the gap between our top income earners and the majority bottom
poor earners is one of the highest in the world and is the reason why Nigeria
stands at number 26 out of 190 countries. So, yes again, there are very deep
challenges that growth did not yet resolve for Nigerians since the early 2000s
when it became normal in the economy.
However,
we can objectively admit that if we had not grown steadily at those higher
rates from 2003 – 2014, the economy would not have expanded as significantly as
it did in the sixteen years of our 1999 cycle of democracy. The expansion of
our GDP offered more diverse opportunities in sectors like telecommunication,
agriculture and agri-business, entertainment and services.
In real
human terms, a growing economy provided more and newer opportunities for
citizens than was the case during the lost decades of the 80s and 90s known
mostly for no, low or negative growth. The concept of economic growth must
therefore not be derided nor dismissed as some usually do.
The fundamental anchor for Nigeria’s long period of economic growth was, when starting since 2003, policy makers managed to achieve macroeconomic stability through an effective mix of monetary, fiscal and some measure of structural policies. Whereas not many citizens would normally concern themselves with the rather arcane concepts that engage the minds of economic and finance technocrats; yet, growth policies are fundamental to economic progress of individuals, households, governments and businesses. This is becoming obvious to Nigerians in the last twelve months as more citizens now better see the relationship between growth and the fact that some who once had a job no longer have one.
The fundamental anchor for Nigeria’s long period of economic growth was, when starting since 2003, policy makers managed to achieve macroeconomic stability through an effective mix of monetary, fiscal and some measure of structural policies. Whereas not many citizens would normally concern themselves with the rather arcane concepts that engage the minds of economic and finance technocrats; yet, growth policies are fundamental to economic progress of individuals, households, governments and businesses. This is becoming obvious to Nigerians in the last twelve months as more citizens now better see the relationship between growth and the fact that some who once had a job no longer have one.
What then
was the genesis of the loss of economic growth? It came from the fact that we
learned nothing from previous mistakes in the manner of poor governance of
resources, especially oil earnings. Nigeria was once again extravagant during
the most recent five years of oil boom. That this happened even after the
country turned the corner in 2003 when it set up oil-based fiscal rules on how
best to save in plenty in order to prepare for the lean period, is all the more
disappointing. Regrettably, in the period between 2010 and 2014 when oil prices
were exceptionally high and several other oil-rich countries were accumulating
reserves, Nigeria was acting out an alternate reality. We were incongruously
borrowing during plenty to expand the consumption habits of all the levels and
arms of government.
The
parlous state of the Nigerian economy on 29th May, 2015 should therefore have
instructed an incisive and urgent macroeconomic stabilization programme to
realign price levels in the economy. If a menu of sound monetary and fiscal
policies that the economy needed on May 29, 2015 had been provided, it would
have sent the right signal to players that there was no cause for alarm. Had
the government made quick and necessary adjustments that corresponded close
enough to the level of impact that a 40 percent sharp drop in government oil
revenue necessitated, the story would most likely be less negative today.
There is
a new level that our post 2014 oil-shocked economy must find for stability in
order to stop tottering reason and so we do need a string of policy responses
that can enable this happen quickly. Such responses would have helped the
economy absorb the shock, reassured investors and consumers, and thereby helped
reasonably retain investor confidence. But that did not happen. The attendant
fiscal pressure and the delayed right policy response were severe enough that
by the end of 2015, economic growth sharply declined to 2.7 percent.
It was a
major mistake that the economy did not get the timely and right type of
policies that could have helped us avoid the calamitous collapse into negative
growth in the last two quarters of 2015 that finally led us into a recession.
The signals of statist economic policy preferences did in fact worsen matters
and set off the wave of uncertainty that dented investor confidence in the
economy. So, it is accurate to conclude that both the preceding and the
successor governments conspired by their actions and inactions to throw the
Nigerian economy into the deep rut from which it must be rescued to avoid
social implosion.
The
record of the government for timely and right action on the economy is however
so far not encouraging. For almost one year, the government delayed right
action on the fuel subsidy regime despite its aggravating impact on fiscal
imbalance. Over the same period it delayed the right action on exchange rate
policy despite its deleterious impact on foreign reserves, the value of the
Naira and the rate of inflation. The government finally retraced its steps on
the wrong petroleum subsidy regime and fixed exchange rate policies some five
and four months ago respectively.
But the
design and implementation of those policy changes were half hearted and
therefore remain doubtful in their fiscal and monetary impact. The reluctance
to fully embrace tested and sound policy options was what minimized the
salubrious impact that the two highlighted key policy changes would ordinarily
have had on stabilizing the economy.
With
inflation- nay, stagflation- now at high double digits of 18% , with the
decline of foreign reserve from $37.3 billion at end of 2014 to $25billion in
September 2016, with an “administrative-floating ” exchange rate regime that
still creates enormous opportunities for corruption and rent seeking arbitrage,
with a high interest rate that poses a stress for the financial sector because
of deteriorating bank asset quality as well as for limited access to credit by
the real sector, with a continuously declining aggregate demand, with a shrinking
gross domestic product, with 2016 budget deficit level of $11billion that still
has unclear sources of financing; what more do we need before citizens stepped
up a demand for the government to retrace its steps from its string of unsound
economic policies?
All the
sobering data are indicators of hugely deteriorating macroeconomic indices. The
more such indices deteriorate, the harder it is for growth to resume. The
macroeconomic stability that poor choice of economic policy helped to unravel
within one year had itself taken many years of arduous work to achieve. When
therefore one hears the rather simplification of the economic recovery antidote
being espoused by the government as “we shall spend our way out of recession”,
it heightens anxiety. When one further hears that the sale of assets-
especially some productive ones – is being proposed as key contribution to the
Budget 2016 deficit financing options of the government, the immediacy of
opposing such intention becomes self evident.
For
Nigeria therefore, the most critical challenge that needs resolving is how to
convince the federal government to urgently retrace its steps back to what it
failed to do since 29th May, 2015. First, it failed to launch a deep fiscal
consolidation program. Second, monetary policies failed to adjust to reflect
new realities. Third, the government failed to present the most ambitious
structural reforms ever that can materially improve the productivity and
competitiveness of all potential existing and new sources of economic growth.
The third
action could achieve the four decade-long diversification goal and help build a
resilient economy that is insulated from the volatility of oil prices in the
future. These three broad actions were and still remain the key things
mandatory for the economy to regain the lost macroeconomic stability that will
drive growth recovery, move us to economic development and shared prosperity.
It is
good economics to stimulate economy through increased government spending in a
time of recession. So, there is a place for the stimulus spending proposed by
the government. However, the economic vision that will arrest the macro
imbalance in the short run must be deeper than the proposed plan to “spend,
spend and spend”. After all, if massive government spending were to be the
solution that can fix our economic failures, then they should never have
happened in the first place based on our public expenditure record. Government
spending has been the albatross of our economy. The current administration has
not communicated any persuasive basis for assuming that it’s proposed spending
will achieve a different set of outcomes without being anchored first on sound
economic policies.
The
current language of “massive spending” is therefore very unnerving because it is
not accompanied with a corresponding agenda for massive restructure of the
behemoth and the governance system that easily widens its mouth to gulp the
largest scale of public resources. By the way, whatever happened to the report
of the Presidential Committee on the Rationalisation and Restructuring of
Federal Government Parastatals, Commissions and Agencies which found that the
cost of governance in Nigeria is one of the highest in the world? Did the
report not recommend the scrapping of 102 statutory agencies on which we
continue to spend scarce resources? Where is the fierce urgency required to
implement this game changing report that can help roll back one of the most
unproductively expensive governance architecture in the world?
I have a simple message: The Federal government should do the right first things, first. Change should begin with those who promised Change!
I have a simple message: The Federal government should do the right first things, first. Change should begin with those who promised Change!
Source Ynaija
No comments:
Post a Comment