Just like in his
previous outings, the ghost of Decree 4 of 1984 is haunting General Muhammadu
Buhari(rtd), presidential candidate of the All Progressives Congress (APC), as
he once again takes another shot at the presidency. The infamous decree which
made the duo of Tunde Thompson and Nduka Irabor of The Guardian newspaper the
first victims of military law, has in recent weeks gained currency with
political rivals using it as a weapon against the former military head of
state.
But Tunde Thompson
believes Buhari’s opponents are deliberately confusing and misleading
Nigerians . In this interview, he lays bare the issues surrounding their
detention and unmasked those behind their ordeal. Excerpts:
Who is Tunde
Thompson?
I am a journalist and
I’ve been a journalist since 1971 when I joined the Daily Times as a trainee
sub-editor. I was there till 1972 when I left for the University of Ibadan to
read Political Science. I was in UI till 1975 but during my vacations I worked
with Daily Times and I didn’t need to apply. Daily Times was at its apogee
then. By 1975 when I tried to return, Daily Times had deteriorated and I
couldn’t even find my way back. Tony Momoh, who was the editor, confided in me
that he couldn’t employ me directly, that my application had to go through the
board and all that. So, in the end, I went back just to say hello and then I
was with Dr. Olu Onagoruwa who said to me “Somebody was asking to see you and
Felix Adenaike called from Ibadan saying Jemibewon had given himself and Tola
Adeniyi a job , to run Daily Sketch and that I was needed. He said Felix told
him that they had been looking for me all over the place”, but I was in Calabar
for my youth service between 1975 and 1976. That he said “Wherever I was, they
were ready to increase my pay.” So, I became the features editor and later
political editor at the Daily Sketch. I was there till the 80s or so when Daily
Times improved a little and I went back to the Editorial Board as a senior lead
writer but for a short while as the firm became worse by 1983 and many of us
had to leave. That was when The Guardian started and I joined The Guardian
later when it become a daily newspaper as a senior diplomatic correspondent.
That was what I was doing before I ran into trouble.
How did your trouble
start?
It all started when I became deeply interested in the people at the Ministry of External Affairs who had been retired. Some people came to me and said they had retired so and so person. Even some of the affected diplomats complained to me as the senior diplomatic correspondent. My child was ill at that time, so I was away for some time, but subsequently, I discovered that embassies and consulates had been closed down and all that, so, I wrote about it. The authorities came for me when I wrote an Op-ed in The Guardian entitled, ‘The Mysteries of External Affairs.’ I questioned why people who had been doing a great job suddenly lost their jobs in so short a time. I went to Nigeria’s mission in Lebanon, as they said Nigeria should re-open its mission in Lebanon. Then I told them government had the right to close down any mission if it was not generating returns. I was defending my country, but I was seen as a security threat. So, that was the beginning of the fire. When the report was out, security people came, asking for the writer of the story. It was an Op-ed page and it was obvious that the name of the writer would be there. When the paper told them that we stood by our story they retreated, but by the time I wrote about some ambassadors being retired and military officers sent to diplomatic missions there was trouble.
It all started when I became deeply interested in the people at the Ministry of External Affairs who had been retired. Some people came to me and said they had retired so and so person. Even some of the affected diplomats complained to me as the senior diplomatic correspondent. My child was ill at that time, so I was away for some time, but subsequently, I discovered that embassies and consulates had been closed down and all that, so, I wrote about it. The authorities came for me when I wrote an Op-ed in The Guardian entitled, ‘The Mysteries of External Affairs.’ I questioned why people who had been doing a great job suddenly lost their jobs in so short a time. I went to Nigeria’s mission in Lebanon, as they said Nigeria should re-open its mission in Lebanon. Then I told them government had the right to close down any mission if it was not generating returns. I was defending my country, but I was seen as a security threat. So, that was the beginning of the fire. When the report was out, security people came, asking for the writer of the story. It was an Op-ed page and it was obvious that the name of the writer would be there. When the paper told them that we stood by our story they retreated, but by the time I wrote about some ambassadors being retired and military officers sent to diplomatic missions there was trouble.
Was it a joint effort
between you and Irabor ?
No it wasn’t. My
grandmother died in Edo State and I had to attend the burial. So, I gave him my
manuscript, being an assistant news editor. When I was in Benin that Sunday, I
sent for the paper and when I saw the report I shouted. I knew something had
gone wrong because somebody I did not talk to was quoted in the story. So, on
February 11, 1984 somebody from Nigeria Security Organisation, NSO, Awolowo
Road, came to pick me up at The Guardian premises and the receptionist said to
me “your friend from Ibadan wants to see you .” To cut the story short, he
insisted that I should follow him. I went to the editor and the legal adviser and
they asked me to comply. At the end of the day, I ended up at Ikoyi, Off
Awolowo Road and that was the beginning of a hell of experience.
What did NSO ask you?
They came on a Friday
knowing that weekend was the best time to subject you to an ordeal with mosquitoes
since nobody could bail you on a weekend. They didn’t question me till the
following Monday. We were kept in 10 x 10 room and we were about 10 . If you
wanted to pee, they told you to knock from inside and they would open from
outside. During questioning, they wanted to know who told me what I wrote. As I
was writing they told me I had to tell them who told me this and that point.
That was the problem. Even at the point of death, a journalist is not expected
to disclose his source. I told them I wouldn’t oblige them adding if I wrote
something they liked, they should applaud me but conversely they could send a
rejoinder and I would publish it. Another questioning session took place about
two days later and they took me to the head of security at that time, Alhaji
Rafindadi. He it was, who really asked me who told me what I wrote. I told him
he was a security man and if I told him that a man in my neigbourhood does not
go to work, that he’s at home from morning till about 9pm or 10pm and by 10 pm he’s
gone and by 6am he is back and he lives big. You investigated and discovered
him to be the kingpin of the underworld. Would he disclose his source ? We are
supposed to obey the same rules about professional ethics. If you won’t tell
him why should you expect me to tell you who told me what I wrote? As I told
your men, if you like what we write, clap for us but if you don’t, send a
rejoinder we will publish it. That was the beginning of it. So, what led to
another person being called was when the man asked me about another story that
was written and that had been embellished. I don’t mean embellishment in an
offensive way but I think the person that did it was doing his job, by adding
additional paragraphs as an assistant editor and that was the source of the
problem. So, I had to confess that I did not work on the story alone that they
would need to call him to confirm or verify what happened.
Was that when they
went for Irabor?
Yes, something
happened after I said that. They decided to go for him and they went for him at
a very interesting time. It was the day Offodile promulgated Decree 4 of 1984,
The Protection of Public Officers against False Accusations Decree at a world
press conference. Incidentally, Nduka Irabor was coming from that conference with
the report when they arrested him and brought him to Ikoyi. He became the
second victim of the decree.
You must have been
detained under Decree 2 ….(cuts in)
There was no Decree
No.4 at the time we committed the so-called offence and there was no basis for
prosecuting us. They could have watched developments and see who would be
caught because the “offences” for which we were prosecuted was committed before
the decree.
That means they made
the decree retroactive?
But that is unacceptable professionally. They made it retroactive and nobody called them to order. Instead there were theatrics in court that if you see a secretary having sex with a Permanent Secretary and a journalist wrote about it, would you arrest the journalist? That was irrelevant to me. But the strategy adopted by The Guardian in court was that we won’t even say a word. So, Nduka and myself did not utter a word because if we uttered a word they could ask us who told us what we said and then if we failed to name our source(s), it would mean that we were subverting the process, that we were trying to sabotage government’s efforts at getting the truth. But you don’t get the truth by forcing people to divulge who told them what they were told. I think that is where the problem arose. What I find interesting now is that people are still talking about this Decree 4 like somebody wanting to know what I felt.
But that is unacceptable professionally. They made it retroactive and nobody called them to order. Instead there were theatrics in court that if you see a secretary having sex with a Permanent Secretary and a journalist wrote about it, would you arrest the journalist? That was irrelevant to me. But the strategy adopted by The Guardian in court was that we won’t even say a word. So, Nduka and myself did not utter a word because if we uttered a word they could ask us who told us what we said and then if we failed to name our source(s), it would mean that we were subverting the process, that we were trying to sabotage government’s efforts at getting the truth. But you don’t get the truth by forcing people to divulge who told them what they were told. I think that is where the problem arose. What I find interesting now is that people are still talking about this Decree 4 like somebody wanting to know what I felt.
For how long were you
in detention before you were taken to court?
Policemen can be very good. They know when there is truth on the side of their master and on the side of the accused. What happened was that I told them to put me on the corridor when Nduka was coming in so that I could alert him about what questions I was being asked. They put me on the corridor and I whispered to him that they had been asking me about foreign missions that had been closed down and then about those that had been appointed as ambassadors or high commissioners and they wanted to know who told me but I refused to tell them. At that point, somebody saw us and raised the alarm that we were talking and I replied that we were not talking but only greeting each other. So, they took Nduka away immediately to another detention room and I was taken back to where I was with about eight to ten others with the air-conditioner making noise to disturb my sleep and mosquitoes viciously attacking us . By the following day or two days after he was taken in for questioning and he was already alerted. We later met when they said they were arranging for us to meet lawyers from Rotimi Williams chambers.
Policemen can be very good. They know when there is truth on the side of their master and on the side of the accused. What happened was that I told them to put me on the corridor when Nduka was coming in so that I could alert him about what questions I was being asked. They put me on the corridor and I whispered to him that they had been asking me about foreign missions that had been closed down and then about those that had been appointed as ambassadors or high commissioners and they wanted to know who told me but I refused to tell them. At that point, somebody saw us and raised the alarm that we were talking and I replied that we were not talking but only greeting each other. So, they took Nduka away immediately to another detention room and I was taken back to where I was with about eight to ten others with the air-conditioner making noise to disturb my sleep and mosquitoes viciously attacking us . By the following day or two days after he was taken in for questioning and he was already alerted. We later met when they said they were arranging for us to meet lawyers from Rotimi Williams chambers.
For how long were you
there before you were taken to court?
From February 11 when
I was arrested and within a week or two, Nduka came in and then we were there
till May when the trial started and up till July 4.
Were you granted
bail?
For where? We were
moved in a very dramatic away from Awolowo Road, to the Maximum Security
Prisons at Kirikiri . They moved both of us into a cell meant for those
awaiting trial . At that time we discovered those who were awaiting trial were
even more than prisoners. There were so many of us and some could not have
their bath for days. So, they depended on us for food, soap and all that.
Can you recall your
day in court?
That was a very
dramatic day I can’t forget. We were whisked out of the premises of the
Kirikiri Maximum Security Prisons between 7am and 7.30 am . Imagine going from
Kirikiri to Ikoyi in Lagos Island ? Consider the distance then with all the
traffic one had to contend with. We got there with policemen on standby. Then I
saw my wife and one of my children and we went in there. In the defence we
prepared overnight, the most important thing there was that the decree was
promulgated after we had been arrested and that it should not have been retroactive.
But our lawyer didn’t raise that point at all. So, I was very unhappy about
that and because we were not allowed to speak from the dock. If we had been
allowed to speak, I could have made the point that we didn’t commit any
offence. I had gone to the Federal Government Press to look for a copy of the
decree to buy after Mr. Omerua who was the Minister of Information said there
would be a decree soon. The decree wasn’t ready when I went there. I wanted to
study it but I didn’t know I would be a victim of it later. I cannot begin to
paint the picture of the whole drama but on that day, everywhere was tense and
it was obvious that freedom was far from us.
Who was the judge?
It was Justice
Ayinde. I understood that there was nothing we could do to convince him. Even
if we had said that the decree was promulgated after the offence it wouldn’t
have made any difference.
How did you feel when
you were convicted and sentenced?
Oh, I felt sorry for
Nigeria. I felt the government had been misled into turning a patriotic journalist
who slept in his office many times to write stories at the Daily Times and
Daily Sketch into a criminal. When Chief Obafemi Awolowo said he did not agree
with the presidential system that was recommended by the Constituent Assembly
in 1975, I was in Daily Sketch then. I told the editor of Sunday Sketch, Sola
Odunfa that I would give him an article. That was on a Thursday. I did not
sleep, I wrote on why the presidential system is superior to the Westminster
model contrary to what Chief Awolowo said. I was at the Constituency Assembly
in 1978 and we told them that the idea of keeping journalists out and asking
them to be briefed by members was wrong. We wondered why they didn’t do
something more acceptable professionally and eventually they decided they
would give us a chance to meet the deputy chairman around lunch time for
briefing and then they would break up by 5 pm or 6pm after the afternoon
session and would have another round of briefing.
Otherwise we would
have to meet each member of the assembly for comments. It means that was
unofficial, it could be tainted with personal opinions. So, it’s now time for
me to say that Decree 4 was just meant to ensure that no professional can step
out of line, that no professional brought the government to ridicule or
embarrassed the government in any way. But when you now say Protection of
Public Officers against False Accusation Decree, what was my offence in saying
an embassy or a mission had been closed? Or that somebody had been retired? In
fact, they were not even quarreling about the retirements because all the
reports were authentic. So, what is the embarrassment there? There was no
accusation in that. That is why government is a wonderful institution, let’s
put it that way. I discovered later that government did not like what happened
because we had in my report about those who were posted, which was also embellished,
names of certain people who were not career diplomats, most of them were
military officers. I think whatever might have irritated or annoyed the
military top brass was that people were phoning them to tell them that this
all-embracing unity government they wanted to form had six out of eight people
from the northern part of the country as ambassadors or high commissioners. Was
that the kind of country they envisaged? I think that must have embarrassed the
government. But that wasn’t false accusation but they were not analyzing grammar.
They just felt embarrassed that people asked them that question. That was why
they asked who gave us information. So, I would say the drama of that day was
something I would never like to be repeated.
How long were you in
jail?
The jail term was one
year, but then one prison year is eight calendar months. So, we were in jail
for eight months. Interestingly, the weekend before we were to be released,
prison inmates organized a football competition and all sorts of competitions
for us. Then something happened. At about 3am they came for us in our cell and
took us to the administrative block of the prison service. When we asked them
what was happening, they said they were taking us to the United Kingdom, and
that I was going to the United States. I asked how possible was that because
we didn’t have visas, we didn’t have passports? They answered that it was
possible because the government could perform wonders. What happened was that
they knew Nigerians , the civil society, had prepared a welcome rally. They
were to stand from Kirikiri and follow us down to our homes. So, they
pre-empted them. By that arrangement, they decided to take us from the prison
and dumped us in our houses before the day we were to be released so that by
Monday, if any civil organisation came to Kirikiri they would find the place
empty. It was like the case of Jesus and the empty tomb.
Where did you live
then?
I lived at Mende, Okupe Estate on Sumaila Street. Let me tell you the joke. My wife and my children had just moved from Shogunle to the place. I gave her a cheque for her to relocate to Maryland but I didn’t know the house. So, when we were released, they took us in a common vehicle through Isolo because Nduka lived around that area. They searched for his house until they got it. As for me, I told them I lived at Sumaila Street so they took me to the street and we saw No.5 but they didn’t believe a journalist could live in that kind of house , because it was too good to them. So, they didn’t bother to knock but instead drove down to the end of the street before they concluded that my house had to be at beginning of the street. So, we went back and behold that was the place.
I lived at Mende, Okupe Estate on Sumaila Street. Let me tell you the joke. My wife and my children had just moved from Shogunle to the place. I gave her a cheque for her to relocate to Maryland but I didn’t know the house. So, when we were released, they took us in a common vehicle through Isolo because Nduka lived around that area. They searched for his house until they got it. As for me, I told them I lived at Sumaila Street so they took me to the street and we saw No.5 but they didn’t believe a journalist could live in that kind of house , because it was too good to them. So, they didn’t bother to knock but instead drove down to the end of the street before they concluded that my house had to be at beginning of the street. So, we went back and behold that was the place.
What time was it when
you got home?
It was around 4 am.
It was like an armed robbery operation. We went in and it was a blissful transformation.
Did they count the
number of days you had spent in detention before you were actually sentenced?
They were not interested in doing that. The sentencing was in July and we were released the following year.
They were not interested in doing that. The sentencing was in July and we were released the following year.
So, how did you feel?
In prison? I wrote a
book, Power of the Press, and it’s based on the experience and all the points
that were made by the late Chief Rotimi Williams that I could recollect. The
arguments of the prosecution and defense counsels were presented from my point
of view and the analysis of the ethical issues involved and the publication of
the statement I made and questions they asked me. I had to respond to an
article that claimed some journalists asked for something but when they were
not given they started making accusations against some leaders claiming that
they didn’t keep their promises. I had to respond to that article about two
years ago in The Sun on the comment by General Buhari, because I believed he
was misled into thinking that those of us, The Guardian staff, who were
involved in the Decree 4 matter wanted something from the government but
because we were not obliged, we decided to write stories. That is not possible.
I responded that the
journalists involved didn’t do that kind of thing; they were not thinking about
material promises made by anybody. As a matter of fact, nobody made such
promises. What happened was that stories were written and sources were demanded
and were denied because it was not ethical. But when you look at it now, this
is 2015, about 31 years later, I have also reflected on the matter especially when
I wanted to do that rejoinder to the comment made by General Buhari that some
journalists made some demands, that the demands were not honored and they
started blackmailing them.
I have seen that time
is a healer of certain wounds because people are still asking that the man who
jailed you wants to become the president that what do I feel about it? They
asked if I would vote for such a man. I want to say categorically that Buhari
as the head of state at the time, didn’t order the detention of Mr. Tunde
Thompson and Nduka Irabor.
He never did. Even
Idiagbon did not. It was the head of NSO that ordered our arrest. That was the
file my colleague saw when he was brought in to see Rafindadi after I had
briefed him. And that was an order that they complied with. Buhari was not
responsible for our arrest, so I do not see why at this time, people are trying
to make political capital out of what happened in 1984. Apart from that, it was
an issue in 2011 election. Between 2010 and 2011 people kept saying this over
and over again. I think it’s now over 30 years, people should learn to be
charitable; they should learn to forgive and let bygones be bygones especially
when we know the truth about who did what. I will like to say that Buhari
didn’t order my arrest, so I bear no grudge against him.
Are you saying if
there was any hurt he’s been forgiven?
Left to me, the hurt
was inadvertent; it was aimed at protecting the government. I know it was not
for journalists alone, there were other professional groups other than journalists
that the decree was targeted at. I am very happy that we faced the bullet and
the bullet was deadened at our end. The press and the government are rivals in
the search for information. They are also rivals in secrecy matters. The
government wants to keep its secrets secret and we want to make the secrets
open because we want to inform our audience. That’s why we always quarrel and
that’s why I believe the government and the media need more fora to understand
themselves. There are hostilities because we don’t understand ourselves.
Are you saying you
wish General Buhari well as he aspires to rule Nigeria?
Yes, as far I am
concerned now and considering the fact that there is an order that the Minister
of Petroleum should not appear before the National Assembly to defend her
conduct and considering the fact that the Naira had been further devalued. Now
listen, in Ghana the Cedi we used to mock, the Rupee we used mock and the Yen.
The Naira is just not there again. We say revalue the Naira but they said they
cannot because we only have one commodity. The government has been saying a lot
about agriculture. Cocoa provided the mainstay of the defunct western region
under Chief Obafemi Awolowo. Groundnuts provided the mainstay of the defunct
northern economy under Sir Ahmadu Bello. Have our farmlands suddenly become
infertile? We have solid minerals; we have gold in Ilesa. What I am trying to
say is that if we look critically, we have other commodities and if they are
harnessed we will be able to say we have more than oil. I appreciate what the
Minister of Agriculture, Akinwunmi Adesina is doing now. Rice is being
produced on massive scale but the problem is mechanization. They are trying to
see if we can grow wheat here. I believe enough efforts have not been made to
find alternative income-generating activities.
Some even seem to be
too powerful. They are sacred cows and they cannot be tamed. Is that not
dangerous? I believe that a person like Buhari at this time can call anybody to
order and some people are afraid of that.
The fear of a few
people who have plundered the treasuries of this country should not be allowed
to hinder our economic progress and political transformation. I think Buhari
is humble. How many times did Abraham Lincoln run for presidency of United
States? Was it not about 11 times? But Buhari is running for about three, four
times and people are saying he is too old. He is not too old. Let them go to
India, let them go to other places there are examples. I will not like people
to use Decree 4 as an excuse to deny somebody, who can help bring discipline
through democratic means, to Nigeria, another opportunity of getting to the
position of president of this country. I think God is getting tired of the
injustice in this country.
That is why some of
us are seeing the reason to rally round the man and support him. The Sun is not
a newspaper for any candidate, it is a national newspaper. I am very happy that
you raised the issue about what my position is on somebody who put me in jail.
I think 30 years is long enough, we should forgive and forget and let there be
progress. Those who are ready to continue confusing issues out of their
ignorance should be pushed aside and let us do what our conscience dictates.
Except we want to suffer for another four or eight years, it will be costly to
make a wrong decision again.
SOURCE: sunnewsonline.com
No comments:
Post a Comment